I’ll start by saying that I have the absolute best youth in the entire world. They constantly amaze me—but I think like any time you are around a group of people, there will certainly be people who, for a period of time, have very little concern for the things of God.
For me, though, I think it all comes back to prayer, and real relationships. The closer I get to the students, the closer they get to Jesus (or at least that is what I hope)—and it works the same way when other God-loving students get closer to their peers…
These things take time, but the more love, care, and attention you give students, the more they’ll trust you. The more you share—the more they will listen. I’ve been at this church for nearly 2 years, and the first several months, I could get nowhere… but God was working.
And I think that’s the key—is that the Holy Spirit does work, even when you feel helpless and useless. The more I try to do, the less I get done, but when I preach the Word, and love on the students, Its amazing to watch their lives transform.
So in short, my recommendation would be to show the kind of longsuffering, patient, love that Paul talks about in 1 Corinthians, and let the Holy Spirit work. :) Hope that helps. Peace and love.